top of page
12_ Cheese 4_25 profile.jpg
flag banner 3.jpg

Pizza

 Our homemade pizzas come in a variety of sizes. 

From our 14"square and 12"rounds to our Sicilian and Grandma pies.

All made with only the freshest ingredients. We pride ourselves in serving 

the tastiest pizza. Whether kicking back watching football or having dinner

with the family, these are always a crowd pleaser.

ital ban 2.jpg

Please contact us for more information on the items below. 

THE BIG CHEESE

Our New York style pizza is a perfect

combination of a thin crispy crust yet remains

soft and thin on the inside. Topped

with our simple sweet tomato sauce and fresh mozzarella. Delicious pizza with historical roots.

ital ban 2.jpg
9_ Cheese 4_26_25.jpg
Margherita.jpg

MARGHERITA

Our classic Margherita pizza is topped

with smooth and creamy Fior di Latte, our

homemade sauce, fresh basil and Pecorino Romano. Just like Nonna use to make.

ital ban 2.jpg

SICILIAN

With it's thick, springy crust covered with our savory homemade tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella and a drizzle of extra virgin olive oil, this Sicilian packs a flavorful punch adorned by everyone.

ital ban 2.jpg
Sicilian_edited.jpg
IMG_4402.heic

THE DUDE

A golden garlic-oil crust layered with

creamy mozzarella, slow-caramelized cipollini onions, earthy mushrooms and fresh-picked

basil. A simple, rustic pizza celebrating deep, natural flavors.

ital ban 2.jpg

PEPPZILLA

Who doesn’t love pepperoni? Made with our delicious marinara sauce, fresh mozzarella, Pecorino Romano and an abundance of pepperoni. Like lil cups of love.

ital ban 2.jpg
9x13 pepperoni.JPG
Grandma profile.jpg

THE CRUSTY NONNA

Our Grandma pizza is packed with flavor,

from the fresh mozzarella on our thin and fluffy crust to the thick plum tomatoes and Pecorino Romano on top. It's like Grandma's house any day of the week!

ital ban 2.jpg

THE RUSTIC VEGGIE

Our veggie pizza is packed with smokey eggplant, buttery artichoke hearts, sweet roasted garlic, sun-cured olives and topped with a drizzle of herb infused olive oil. All layered on a bubbly, golden crust. A true taste of the earth.

ital ban 2.jpg
12_ Art,roasted gar,eggplant,olives.jpg

FICO BIANCO DOLCE

Bring the trattoria home with our rustic three cheese white pizza. A combination of ricotta, fresh mozzarella and Pecorino Romano topped roasted garlic, fig jam, cracked black pepper and basil. You'll be craving it all the time.

ital ban 2.jpg

AMATRICIANA

Rome on a crust. Smokey guanciale meets tangy tomato, sweet onions and sharp Pecorino. All fired up with a chili kick and melted Fior di Latte.

ital ban 2.jpg
IMG_7260.heic

THE CARNIVORE

This masterful meat medley is packed with Italian sausage, savory meatballs and crispy pepperoni. Along with fresh mozzarella and Pecorino Romano. This pizza will have vegetarians thinking twice. 

ital ban 2.jpg

ROCKET 

Crunchy and creamy meets fresh and zippy.

Our burrata and arugula pizza is topped with vine ripe tomatoes, creamy burrata, peppery arugula and a drizzle of balsamic glaze with a pinch of crushed red pepper.

ital ban 2.jpg
Overhead Bur_arug cut_edited.jpg

CAUGHT A CRAVING? CONTACT US 

ital ban 2.jpg

Please complete the form below and we will get back to you ASAP.

If you plan to order multiple pizzas, focaccias or sides, please specify
which pizza(s) or focaccia(s) in the comments below. 

Delivery guy_edited.jpg
  • Instagram
  • Facebook
Gargano Pizza NYC FINAL LOGO floating_ed

Join Our Mailing List

Thanks for submitting!

bottom of page